Thu 24 May

Monday 14 March 2011

Bookmark and Share

Yasi - What have we learnt?

 

by Mat Churchill

Without any doubt, Port Douglas and our region as a whole was extremely lucky that the category five tropical cyclone Yasi, predicted to be one of the biggest storms ever to hit Queensland, tracked south in the hours before it reached landfall.

But human nature dictated that, despite the media coverage of devastation in places like Cardwell, Tully and Innisfail in the days and weeks to come, it didn't take long for us to return to our daily lives almost oblivious to the danger we had diverted, or which had diverted us.

But what would have happened if the predicted 300km/h winds and metres of storm surge had have hit Port Douglas head on, as was looking highly likely even up until the day before the event?

The question of evacuation was one of the most talked about topics in the lead up. Where were people to go if and when the call came to leave our homes?

Mossman's evacuation centre at the sports complex was reportedly home to around 250 people, and by all accounts few more could have found room. The Newsport was told of a power blackout, and the lack of generator at the centre meant people endured many hours in stifling conditions.

But the issue of comfort is secondary. The issue surely is where would the thousands of other residents of Mossman, Port Douglas, Cooya, Wonga, and other populated areas in the region go if the worst of the category five cyclone hit us?

It's easy to forget the apprehension we all felt prior to Yasi's arrival. Now that it has been and gone, what's even easier to forget is to ask the question: Am I any wiser about what to do when the next cyclone comes?

Here's a hypothetical situation for you to consider.

We get wind of another category five tropical cyclone (let's call it 'Roy' after my editor) which is due to reach us in two days time. The Bureau of Meteorology can't predict with total accuracy where the storm will track but it's likely Port Douglas will encounter extreme weather conditions (much like Yasi).

Storm surges of three metres are predicted, but because of the uncertainty about where the storm will finally hit land, and the price of plane tickets out of Cairns has skyrocketed, the time comes quickly where you have been advised that the window of opportunity to leave has closed.

This time 'Roy' doesn't track south like Yasi did, and Port Douglas and Mossman feel the full brunt of the winds which destroys building with a cyclone rating of less than four, and the storm surge which floods all low lying areas.

With a regional population in the thousands, and an evacuation centre which holds 300 at best, what happens to everyone else?

This story isn't out of the realms of possibility. It was only through category five luck that we didn't experience it a few weeks ago. We were told that this year would be one of the most active for cyclones ever.

So the question remains. Are you any wiser about what to do when the next cyclone comes?

If not, surely the question of how disasters are managed and their affects minimised in our region needs to be asked of authorities as it's just a matter of time before there is a next time.

Have your say!

We welcome your comments. To ensure the forum remains constructive please respect other peoples comments. Any comment submitted will only be published if name and valid email address are supplied for publication.  The Editor reserves the right to edit comments. Click here for full publishers terms and conditions for reader comments.


 

Jill Booth, 31-03-11 00:36:
When I phoned Council the day before Yasi was due to hit us and the Premier and Mayor were urging us to evacuate low lying areas, they didn't know where Port's evacuation centre was as they were waiting for Brisbane (yes, incredibly, someone in Brisbane!) to tell them.

DSC had designated cyclone shelters in Port Douglas as well in Mossman but I suppose those records were destroyed along with other vital information when we were colonised by Cairns.
Ying Tee, 22-03-11 12:27:
JULATTEN is setting up a local DISASTER MANAGEMENT GROUP. We have got support from the Council and have a few key people signed up to drive the community audit and planning. We will be working in conjunction with council, the local firies, the SES and any other members of the community to develop very specific practical actions and plans for Julatten. We will be specifically looking at cyclone and flood mitigation, the management and provision for coastal evacuees, and planning for basic needs of food, water, shelter, power and communications.
If you would like to part of the group or would like help in setting up your local group, please contact the JULATTEN COMMUNITY CENTRE on 4094 2037.
Rod Davis Davis, 18-03-11 20:32:
If a Yasi headed to Port, I would head to the carpark of my old Boathouse..its 10 times more secure that a steel gym shed, designed to about Cat 4.
steve hull, 18-03-11 08:29:
i don't think there is any need to drop the waterfront developement plan,it would also be a great asset to our town.
it's more about not missing this next wave of infrastructure spending,and using it where it is most needed/important.
with the growth predicted for our region,in cairns post edition 17/3/11,it is vital we get our fair share of the pie this time around,it may be our last chance for a long,long time
Gazza Tee, 17-03-11 23:00:
Plan for the worse. Always expect the unexpected. There was a lot of uncertainty and worry with conflicting messages from different sources. Even 12,000 miles away, getting frantic calls from my kin in Port as to what to do as the clock ticked down was worrying. In the end the kids went into the highlands and hunkered-down at some friends home. But prior to that they were confused and concerned with the advice given. One source told them to head south to Tully (suicide) another to Mareeba (but where?)while another said stay put (duh!). Port Douglas was lucky, but as in a game of Russian Roulette, sooner or later the luck runs out. Please, look after yourselves in paradise.... :)
philip dalziel, 17-03-11 22:38:
think most of the resorts were a little dissapointed that yasi did'nt wipe them out so the insurance would kick in and transport them from the 80's to now
Lisa-Jean Brough, 17-03-11 22:11:
MMMMMMmmmmm!!! What a subject. Now that my eldest daughter and I live apart and she has her own life, its very hard to convey the importance of safety as we all have our own ideas. I no longer live in Port and now live in Clifton Beach. But yet I did not stay in my own home due to my neighbours huge trees that I viewed to be a danger to our safety and well being in the possibility of 'Kiss My Yasi' Hitting us full on. My main concern was our safety and the safety of my eldest daughter still in Port with her boyfriend. I mean for everyone but family is first eh????? I think too many people regardles of how long they have lived in Port, can take these matters a bit TOO lightly. I have had the privilege of knowing much about Port Douglas over the years but too much is not done for those that don't know. WHERE is the safety for the locals, WHERE do we keep the safety of our tourists, why is a safety place such secret business. I guess at the end of the day what use to be our safe place is now no longer a safe place. REALLY do we have one????? Have we considered ALL aspects not just CYCLONE but also TSUNAMI. Come on guys this is 2011, how do we protect oursleves, in Port Douglas or in Cairns cuz really nobody has a TRUE strategy in place and a TRUE safe place. I ran to a freinds place, but were we really safe???? I tried to convince my daughter her and boyfriend to come to the same place we were but were we really safe? Or were they safer in their own home in Port Douglas. Come on Council do the right thing keep us safe when we need to be kept safe. Cyclones give us a warning earthquakes dont and Tsnuamis don't give us enough warning. Give us a safe place to go and a true and accurate warning setup before you give us a new Entertainment Precinct. Protect us first so we are NOT another JAPAN. God Bless Them ALL!!!!! Please take this seriously YOU have been warned, look at NZ look at Japan. What more do you need to wake up. I mean HELLO, QLD Floods, 'Kiss My Yasi' all in a couple of months. Sort it resolve it or be sued for NOT protecting us after ALL these warnings around us.
Peter Lloyd, 16-03-11 23:30:
Forget about the waterfront plan,put the money into building a evacuation centre either in Mossman or Port Douglas, the last exeperince (yatsi) was a joke,The sports centre had No Power,No Cooking facilities,ect,we do not live in a third world country and deserve better treatment from our state goverment, lets get together and make sure all our residents of our shire have somewhere safe to go before the next big scare,it will come one day
Mat Churchill, 15-03-11 12:05:
Make sure you vote on The Newsport Poll on the homepage regarding the adequacy of evacuation facilities in Douglas.
Sam Cullen , 15-03-11 09:13:
I was horrified at myself that after Cyclone Larry I had not put in place a cyclone evacuation plan. It wasn't until I was staring into the face of Yasi like the rest of us that I organised a makeshift plan to evacuate to a high ground and secure structure. I must admit post Yasi I haven't given it two thoughts again. Where would we go if another serious cyclone came over us and I mean actually over us or even worse just to the North.

It is amazing what we all learn when we have to. Talk about a crash course in first, second, third and fourth quadrants of a cyclone. Anyway what for us now? Should we not be reviewing the community awareness procedures that were quite effective in reaching us but left many people very confused. Can we not have a definitive cyclone instruction and evacuation plan provided.

Talk about getting away with it. Remember the Tsunami warning when we all had no idea. I felt a little like this. What would of happened if Yasi had come over the top of us. Droves of people were evacuated (reports of a thousand plus) with very few suggestions of where to go. People were left to luck it out with friends and strangers. The Mossman Sports Centre option was not enough.

We need a Yasi debrief that would include confirmation of reliable access to storm surge information, confirmation that we will improve warnings and alert information and access to dedicated evacuation options with generator and emergency provisions.

Have we become too complacent with all the close calls but no real damage. Perhaps with the anniversary of the 100 year cyclone upon us we will act as if the next one will get us ! Plan now for 2012 Cyclone Season !
Russell Jean, 15-03-11 01:05:
We should realise we dodged a bullet with Yasi and were lucky. Will we be that lucky next season?? Doesn't seem like anyone cares as we haven't done anything since Yasi?? No new plans, identified evacuation centres or put anything in place and next season isn't far away. We need a cyclone evacuation centre and we need to get it under way NOW!! NO, the new school hall is not sufficient as it would hold only about 50 people, no toilets/showers and only Cat 4 rating - The State Govt say it is the one?? Come on State Govt do something for us up here, give us a centre like Cooktown - A cyclone evacuation centre and community events centre. Let's get together as a community and get something sorted for our community so we have somewhere to go that will hold a lot more numbers, have power, cooking facilities etc etc and NOT what was supposed to have been a well organised place in Mossman for Yasi??? Please let me know if you want to know more I was on the committee for the Cooktown Centre. We need something now !!
steve hull, 14-03-11 11:16:
there is no doubt that we need an evacuation centre in port douglas.

we as a family(like many other local families) evacuated our home and moved into the main street to the saftey of higher
grounds,concrete and bricks & mortar.

the million dollar question is how do you fit everyone into the one evacuation centre?
the answer is you can't.

so maybe its the order of evacuation-ie those in low lying areas in danger of storm surge,according to the councils charts????.
all of our neighbors stayed,but we have children and are in a low lying area.
also not everyone wants to leave their homes during cyclones !!

having an evacuation centre in port douglas would also have other benefits for the whole community.
the one near completion up at cooktown at the moment is a cracker,
it has generators,commercial kithen,multi-sports facilities,swimming pool/gym.
what an asset something like that would be to our town.

Add comment

* - required field

*
*
*
   *
*

To top

Port douglas news daily